o____       ###   #####  #####
   /    /___   #   #    #    #
  /____/   /   #        #    ####
 /    /___/    #   #    #    #
/               ###     #    #     µTCG
    o____
   /    /___
  /____/   /
 /    /___/
/  ###   #####  #####
  #   #    #    #
  #        #    ####
  #   #    #    #
   ###     #    #     µTCG

> back()

Design Diary: Playtesting and Development

{ "published": "", "author": "@hollis" }

Hello hackers!

Apologies for the delay, but I bring you now the second installment in the CTF Design Diary series. Where we last left off, I’d just committed to bringing CTF to the PNW Tabletop Market, and I was left with five months to refine the game loop, develop the card set, figure out a distribution model, do some graphic design, make the website, and actually print the game. Piece of cake, right?

Randomization

The most immediate problem the first rough playtest revealed was that the full random approach wouldn’t cut it. The game was dependent enough on synergies between cards that I couldn’t just give everyone a random set of cards in the right colors and expect the resulting games to be fun. I needed to give players a consistent starting point and then let them explore the possibility space of the game from there.

But I wasn’t ready to abandon randomization—core to the concept of the tabletop market submission was the tiny TCG form factor. I wanted to evoke the 90s-style experience of discovering cards through trading and play. What if I had two kinds of products: starter packs and boosters? Starter packs could have two preconstructed decks (everything you need for two players to play their first game out of the box) and be designed for a fun first game; booster packs could have the weirder cards that require effort to build around.

First Formal Playtests

With the distribution model in mind, I shifted to scheduling regular playtests so I could fill out the card file; after all, I couldn’t build the starter decks until I knew what cards I had at my disposal. For the first round of playtests, I printed out 1-2 full sets of cards, spread them out on the table, and let my testers freely build decks from whatever caught their attention. The focus of these tests was on making sure most every card got some play time, answering as many of these questions as possible:

Cards that nobody wanted to play or that attracted players in theory but disappointed them in practice were cut. Cards that were clearly too powerful or that obviously didn’t have meaningful counterplay were nerfed. New cards were added frequently. Terminology was refined (colors became “disciplines”), and the visual design of the cards was updated to improve readability.

I’ll note that balance was explicitly a non-goal. I didn’t have the time or the playtesting resources to ensure there was no runaway best deck, so I accepted that possibility and focused more generally on fun and flavor. That doesn’t mean no balance changes were made—autostrike originally didn’t discard itself!—but it wasn’t the guiding light.

As the playtest groups scaled up, I formalized my feedback collection. I printed paper cards with forms my testers could fill out to let me know if they had thoughts on individual cards, if they built a deck they thought was cool, or if they wanted a playtesting credit on the website.

Building the Starter Decks

Once the card set felt like it was mostly stable, I laid out all of the cards on the dining room table and arranged them into ten preconstructed decks (one for each pair of disciplines). I then matched each deck up with another one that didn’t overlap in disciplines and that felt like it might be a good matchup, forming five different starter packs. With those built, I scheduled another few playtest sessions focused on refining them. The big questions for each matchup were:

As before, balance concerns took a backseat to the first game being fun and interesting. I had to make a few individual card and entire deck swaps, but eventually I was satisfied that the starter packs provided a good introduction to CTF.

The finalized starter pack lists also locked in card rarities:

Designing Booster Packs

After the introductory experience was mostly settled, I started planning out booster packs. CTF is a small game, so it would make sense for boosters to be small. I wanted them to be chiefly cards new players hadn’t seen yet, so I limited most of the packs’ contents to [★★] and [★★★] cards. But on the other hand, I didn’t want players opening a bunch of cards that couldn’t go in any of their decks, so I decided to collate packs so they contain one card of each discipline—that way, at least 4 of them match any starter pack.

But it wouldn’t be a TCG without foils, so each pack would also contain a foil card of any rarity, including a team card or a reload.

With the starter packs and boosters mapped out, I could so some math and order everything from the printer!

*    *    *    *

But we’ll have to wait for the next Design Diary to find out how my math worked out. Minor spoiler: I made some critical mistakes!

One moment though! Before I finish this post, it feels appropriate to share some early (not final) renders of the revised green edition cards releasing next year. I’ll have more to say about the process closer to release, and check out the official Bluesky account over the next few weeks for photos of the first series of test prints.

Check out breakthrough!
Check out autostrike!
Check out turnabout!

/// @hollis signing off